Tornadoes in a Bucket

In nature, some powerful tornadoes form additional tornadoes within their shear layer. These subvortices revolve around the main tornado, causing massive destruction in their wake. In the laboratory, researchers create a similar multi-tornado system with a spinning disk at the bottom of a shallow, cylindrical layer of water. Depending on how fast the disk spins, different numbers of subvortices form around the main vortex.

In this poster, researchers show the transition from a 3-subvortex system to a 2-subvortex one. Starting at the 12 o’clock position and moving clockwise, we see 3 subvortices arranged in a triangle. A sudden change in the disk’s rotation speed destabilizes the system, causing the subvortices to break down and shift into a new 2-subvortex configuration. As this happens, material that was isolated in each subvortex (darker blue regions) is suddenly able to mix. That suggests that a real-world multiple vortex tornado might suddenly shed debris if it lost enough angular momentum. Back in the lab, though, the shift to a stable 2-subvortex system once again isolates material in individual subvortices and prevents it from mixing with the rest of the flow. (Image and research credit: G. Di Labbio et al. 1, 2)