Tag: vortex ring collision

Turbulence From Vortex Rings
When vortex rings collide, they reconnect into smaller, rings that eventually break down into chaos. Here, researchers experiment with colliding multiple vortex rings — focusing on an eight-ring collision. When they collide rings over and over, it creates a zone of isolated turbulence at the heart of the collisions.
Many of the theories and predictions that exist around turbulence assume that the flow is homogeneous and isotropic; what this means is that the (statistical) characteristics of the flow are the same in every direction. In reality, this kind of flow isn’t always easily achieved, which makes testing theoretical predictions challenging.
What’s neat about this set-up is that you get this desired turbulence in a very controlled way. It’s easy to tune the size and energy of your vortex rings, and those tweaks allow you to observe what — if any — changes occur in the resulting turbulence. (Image and video credit: T. Matsuzawa et al.)
January 4, 2023
Vortex Collisions Leave Clues to Turbulence
Vortex ring collisions have long been admired for their beauty, but they’re now shedding light on the fundamental interactions that lead to turbulence. By dying just the cores of colliding vortex rings (Image 2), researchers observed anti-symmetric perturbations that develop along each core as they interact. These are indicative of what’s known as the elliptical instability.
But the breakdown doesn’t stop there. Instead, as the elliptical instability develops, it generates a set of secondary vortex filaments that wrap around the original cores (Image 3). Just like the original vortex cores, those counter-rotating secondary filaments interact with one another, develop their own elliptical instability, and generate a set of smaller, tertiary filaments (Image 4).
What’s exciting is that this process gives us a physical mechanism for the turbulent energy cascade. Researchers have talked for decades about energy passing from large-scale eddies to smaller and smaller ones, but this work lets us actually observe that cascade in the form of smaller and smaller pairs of vortex filaments interacting. To see more, check out some of our previous posts on this work. (Image and research credit: R. McKeown et al.; via Cosmos; submitted by Ryan M. and Kam-Yung Soh)
March 4, 2020
Vortex Ring Collisions
One of the most enduringly popular submissions I receive is T. Lim’s experimental footage of two vortex rings colliding head-on. It’s an devilishly tough experimental set-up to master because perfectly aligning the rings is incredibly difficult. The pay-off, however, is huge because the breakdown of the colliding rings and their transformation into secondary rings is breathtaking. Destin at Smarter Every Day and his team have worked hard to recreate the experiment (top video), but they’re not the only ones – nor are they the first in decades – to do so.
Ryan McKeown and a team at Harvard have a set-up of their own for vortex ring collisions, and you can see a little of it in action in the middle video. Ryan’s set-up is, frankly, incredible. It scans a light sheet through the vortex rings at high-speed, allowing him to capture the collision and break-up in minute detail in both space and time. What you see in the latter half of his video is a digital reconstruction of that data – not a simulation but real data! His work is capturing vortex collisions in unprecedented detail, allowing researchers to probe the smallest scales of the phenomenon.
When two vortex rings approach one another, they can undergo what’s known as a vortex reconnection event. Bubbles rings are a great place to see this. The vortex cores get distorted when they’re close to one another due to the influence of the other vortex ring’s velocity field. This often stretches and flattens the vortex core. It’s impossible for the rings to simply break apart, though, (per Helmholtz’s second theorem). So when the original vortex rings thin to the point of breaking, they immediately reconnect to a piece of the other ring, creating a series of small vortex rings around the remains of the originals. The exact details of how this works are what investigators like Ryan and his colleagues are trying to understand. You can hear a little more about their work in my interview with Ryan in the bottom video, starting at ~2.54. (Video credits: Smarter Every Day, R. McKeown et al., and N. Sharp and T. Crawford; submission credit: a huge number of readers)
July 3, 2018