Tag: vortex reconnection

Vortex Ring Collisions
One of the most enduringly popular submissions I receive is T. Lim’s experimental footage of two vortex rings colliding head-on. It’s an devilishly tough experimental set-up to master because perfectly aligning the rings is incredibly difficult. The pay-off, however, is huge because the breakdown of the colliding rings and their transformation into secondary rings is breathtaking. Destin at Smarter Every Day and his team have worked hard to recreate the experiment (top video), but they’re not the only ones – nor are they the first in decades – to do so.
Ryan McKeown and a team at Harvard have a set-up of their own for vortex ring collisions, and you can see a little of it in action in the middle video. Ryan’s set-up is, frankly, incredible. It scans a light sheet through the vortex rings at high-speed, allowing him to capture the collision and break-up in minute detail in both space and time. What you see in the latter half of his video is a digital reconstruction of that data – not a simulation but real data! His work is capturing vortex collisions in unprecedented detail, allowing researchers to probe the smallest scales of the phenomenon.
When two vortex rings approach one another, they can undergo what’s known as a vortex reconnection event. Bubbles rings are a great place to see this. The vortex cores get distorted when they’re close to one another due to the influence of the other vortex ring’s velocity field. This often stretches and flattens the vortex core. It’s impossible for the rings to simply break apart, though, (per Helmholtz’s second theorem). So when the original vortex rings thin to the point of breaking, they immediately reconnect to a piece of the other ring, creating a series of small vortex rings around the remains of the originals. The exact details of how this works are what investigators like Ryan and his colleagues are trying to understand. You can hear a little more about their work in my interview with Ryan in the bottom video, starting at ~2.54. (Video credits: Smarter Every Day, R. McKeown et al., and N. Sharp and T. Crawford; submission credit: a huge number of readers)
July 3, 2018
Vortex Reconnection
In slow motion, vortex rings can be truly stunning. This video shows two bubble rings underwater as they interact with one another. Upon approach, the two low-pressure vortex cores link up in what’s known as vortex reconnection. Note how the vortex rings split and reconnect in two places – not one. According to Helmholtz’s second theorem a vortex cannot end in a fluid–it must form a closed path (or end at a boundary); that’s why both sides come apart and together this way. After reconnection, waves ripple back and forth along the distorted vortex ring; these are known as Kelvin waves. Some of those perturbations bring two sides of the enlarged vortex ring too close to one another, causing a second vortex reconnection, which pinches off a smaller vortex ring. (Image source: A. Lawrence; submitted by Kam-Yung Soh)
Note: As with many viral images, locating a true source for this video is difficult. So far the closest to an original source I’ve found is the Instagram post linked above. If you know the original source, please let me know so that I can update the credit accordingly. Thanks!
August 2, 2017
Reconnecting
Vortices are a common feature of many flows. Here we see a helical vortex tube spinning in a swirling flow. The vortex itself is visible thanks to air trapped in its low-pressure core. As the vortex spins, two sections of it come together. This results in what’s known as vortex reconnection: the vortex lines break apart and rejoin in a new configuration – as a small independent vortex ring and a shorter section of helical vortex. Events like this are common but usually hard to observe directly. They’ve been previously visualized using vortex knots and have even been sighted in the quantum vortices of superfluid helium. (Image credit: S. Skripkin, source; research credit: S. Alekseenko et al., pdf)
June 15, 2017
Knotting Vortices
Knots have long fascinated humans, appearing in art for thousands of years and generating entire fields of study. Until recently, however, the idea of a knotted fluid was purely theoretical. To knot fluids, researchers used 3D printing to create twisted hydrofoil shapes. When towed through water, fluid travels around the shape and spins up at the trailing edge, creating a knotted vortex ring. The knotted vortices were captured with 3D imaging, allowing scientists to observe how they evolve. So far the knots they’ve created have all been unstable, deforming until two vortex lines approach one another. Upon contact, the vortices disconnect and reconnect with one another, unraveling the knot. Intriguingly, these vortex reconnections seem remarkably similar to the vortex reconnections observed between quantized vortices in superfluids. (Video credit: D. Kleckner et al.)
February 25, 2014
Superfluid Vortices
Cooling helium to a few degrees Kelvin above absolute zero produces superfluid helium, a substance with some very bizarre behaviors caused by a lack of viscosity. Superfluids exhibit quantum mechanical properties on a macroscopic scale; for example, when rotated, a superfluid’s vorticity is quantized into distinct vortex lines, known as quantum vortices. These vortices can be visualized in a superfluid by introducing solid tracer particles, which congregate inside the vortex line, making it appear as a dotted line, as shown in the video above. When these vortex lines approach one another, they can break and reconnect into new vortices. These reconnections provoke helical Kelvin waves, a phenomenon that had not been directly observed until the present work by E. Fonda and colleagues. They are even able to show that the waves they observe match several proposed models for the behavior. (Video credit: E. Fonda et al.)
November 27, 2012